For Nathan, Who Left Us
You are tall and I imagine your tallness loping through New York City
down the long arch streets of Brooklyn or I don’t know wherever
the young art school students are situating themselves these days.
I forget about you a lot. You become a sort of shadow and people who
know you from back then will recognize that this is both a joke and
a very heartbreaking fact which we have no choice but to accept.
It was funny for everyone except you when you kept smoking
everyone else’s cigarettes because you claimed you were trying to quit
and it was funny for you and no one else when you broke Joe’s guitar cable
at that show in the living room of that fashion student no one seemed to
know.
What made it such a big deal was that you never said sorry.
Never mind the impossibility of forgetting the past, you are
going to cut it clean off like a malignant growth by disappearing
into New York City and refusing to call any of us back so that
now all we know about you comes secondhand. Like that you were
kicked out of your first apartment because you were smoking in it
even though the kid who let you stay in the living room for way less
than his own rent had asked you politely to not do that anymore.
Or that you’re trying to sleep with a girl who sleeps with girls. At least
it is because you love her or think you do. Remember your broken heart
last March when you were still talking to us and at a party in the city
you found her and the girl who would later take Dan’s virginity tribbing in a
closet?
So never mind the impossibility of converting a lesbian and never mind
that all we wanted to hear was some sort of apology or that we didn’t want
you
moving from your parents’ basement in New Jersey because we didn’t want
you
to end up trying to live off of a barista’s salary and selling your guitars
to make rent which is exactly what has happened to you. At least we think
it is but everything we know comes from other people as if you were a ghost
and these strange art-punks a collection of psychically fucked mediums
we pay by the hour to call after you. We can never know if what they
tell us you’re saying back is true because it is never you that shows up for the
séance.
Only once in a great while we get a slim replica, a tall beautiful man who buys
someone a shot and then goes back to the hard work of forgetting
rolling all of us like a boulder of limbs up some terrible mountain in Manhattan.